Research Article |
Corresponding author: Mohd Rafii Yusop ( mrafii@upm.edu.my ) Academic editor: Robert Gabriel
© 2024 Ibrahim Musa, Mohd Rafii Yusop, Usman Magaji, Samuel Chibuike Chukwu, Isma’ila Muhammad, Arolu Fatai Ayanda, Bashir Yusuf Rini, Audu Sanusi Kiri.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Musa I, Yusop MR, Magaji U, Chukwu SC, Muhammad I’ila, Ayanda AF, Rini BY, Kiri AS (2024) Morphological and molecular diversity of eggplant accessions (Solanum melongena L) using simple sequence repeats (SSR) markers. Innovations in Agriculture 7: 1-9. https://doi.org/10.3897/ia.2024.124261
|
The evaluation of various desirable traits in eggplant genotypes has facilitated the efficient process of selecting and improving them. Morphological parameters have proven to be valuable in assessing the similarities or differences among different accessions, while molecular data have been used to support the conclusions drawn from the morphological analysis. This study was conducted to evaluate the performance of 42 eggplant genotypes collected from Malaysia, China, and Thailand. The characteristics under investigation were shown to be highly significant (p < 0.01) by analysis of variance (ANOVA). It was noted that the plants TV17 (5.59 kg) and MV18 (5.97 kg) produced large yields per plant. The SSR markers used exhibited moderate average values for the number of alleles (2.53). The major allele frequency displayed a high average value (0.53) and a moderate average number of effective alleles (2.31). Additionally, the observed Shannon’s information index, expected heterozygosity, and PIC were high (0.84, 0.54, and 0.45, respectively). Using the unweighted pair-group approach with arithmetic averages based on similarity matrices (UPGMA) Dendrogram, 42 accessions were sorted into five primary groups based on similarities. The findings of this study indicate that the use of simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers can effectively estimate genetic diversity and analyze phylogenetic relationships. Moreover, these markers can assist eggplant breeders in selecting desirable quantitative traits within their breeding program.
Eggplant, phenotyping, genotyping, SSR marker, molecular diversity
Eggplant, scientifically known as Solanum melongena L., is a significant crop in the Solanaceae family. Commonly referred to as brinjal or aubergine, this vegetable holds significant agricultural importance in subtropical, tropical, and warm temperate regions (
The 42 eggplant accessions, which form three main populations from Malaysia (19 genotypes), China (6 genotypes), and Thailand (17 genotypes), were used for this study, as presented in Table
New codes | Original name | New codes | Original code |
---|---|---|---|
MV1 | Mini eggplant (214) | CV3 | China-3 |
MV2 | Eggplant-Round Purple (311) | CV4 | Mukta kashi |
MV3 | Green world (white eggplant 330) | CV5 | Pahuja |
MV4 | AG seeds (F1 418 purple king) | CV6 | Eggplant Bhagan |
MV5 | AG seeds (F1 428 Nyonya) | TV1 | Long eggplant 02645/2551 |
MV6 | Little Nyonya 313 F1 hybrid | TV2 | Round eggplant 00558/2551 |
MV7 | Super Naga 312 (F1 Hybrid) | TV3 | Round eggplant 01451/2551 |
MV8 | MTe 2 Eggplant (Terung Bulat) | TV4 | Eggplant Long 01166/2551 |
MV9 | HV-318 (F-2522) | TV5 | Eggplant 1745/2550 |
MV10 | Terong Baling (T E 204) | TV6 | Eggplant 1253/2561 |
MV11 | V-230 (Eggplant) | TV7 | White east west seed |
MV12 | K-82 (Terung Mini) | TV8 | Eggplant El rye |
MV13 | Eggplant (Terung Bulat) | TV9 | Eggplant 01450/2551 |
MV14 | White Crown | TV10 | Metro seed round |
MV15 | White Princess | TV11 | Eggplant parody |
MV16 | Gwauta | TV12 | Eggplant 914/2558 |
MV17 | Purple Dream (302) | TV13 | Round Eggplant (Chao paya) |
MV18 | K-62 (Terung Panjang) | TV14 | Round eggplant 01451/2551 |
MV19 | K 94 (Terung Putih) | TV15 | Round 01388/2552 |
CV1 | Round eggplant 0138/2552 | TV16 | Round eggplant Metro seed |
CV2 | Eggplant Black Beauty | TV17 | Eggplant 408/2556 |
The eleven sets of growth, yield and yielding data were collected and measured under open field cropping conditions. They yield traits include fruit weight (FW), average fruit weight (AFW), fruit length in cm (FL), fruit width in mm (FD), fruit length/width (FL/W), number of fruits per plant (NF/P), and yield per plant (Y/P). While the growth parameters include number of branches per plant (NBPP), plant height (PH), first harvest (PH), and flowering days to 50% (D50%F). All data measurements and observations were conducted on the same day to minimize variations in the developmental stage of plant growth or environmental conditions.
Using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA), all growth, yield, and yield-related data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA), and means were separated using the least significant difference (LSD) at a 5% level of significance. For every attribute that was tested, the mean and standard deviation were also noted.
A modified cetyl trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) technique was used to extract genomic DNA from early leaves (3 to 4 weeks old) of the 42 genotypes of eggplant (
Primers | Forward sequence | Reverse sequence |
---|---|---|
emf01K16 | ATTTGGACAAGAACAAGGATGGCT | GTTTCACTCACAATTCGAGACACTCGGT |
emb01D10 | AAGAATCGGTCCTCTTTGCATTGT | TGCTTTTCACCTCTCCGCTATCTC |
emh21J12 | ACAGAACAATTCACCAGCAGTCAA | GTTTAGGAACAGGGAAAATCGTATCGGT |
SSR–46 | AATAAAGTTATGCCACAGGGC | CACCCTTCACCACCAACAAT |
emh02E08 | AGGCGTTCAGCAGAGAAGAAATTA | GTTTGCTTCCTTAAGTGGCATCTGAAA |
emh11I06 | ATTTCAAACCGTTCCTCTGCTCTT | GTTTGCACAATCATCAAGGCTCCTCTTT |
eme05B09 | ATGAAAACTCCACTCTACTCTACTCCAC | GTTTGCTAACGTACGCCTCAATTGCTCT |
SSR40 | TGCAGGTATGTCTCACACCA | TTGCAAGAACACCTCCCTTT |
emk04N11 | ATCTCCCCCTCAACTTTGAACAAT | GTTTGTGTGATATAGCCCAACAATTCAC |
emf01E10 | ACATATCCAACTGACCTCGGAAGA | GTTTAACCGCTTTGTCCCCAAATACAG |
emf21K08 | ATCAATGACACCCAAAACCCATTT | GTTTGAAAACCCAATACAAATCCGA |
eme05B10 | ATGAAAACTCCACTCTACTCTACTCCAC | GTTTGCTAACGTACGCCTCAATTGCTCT |
emk03O04 | ATGATTTGGGCAGCCACTTTTGTA | GTTTGGAACCAACTAAACTTAGGGCA |
emb01C12 | AAAAAGCTCTGCCCAAACAAGC | GACTTTCCTCACTAATTCACAACCA |
emh11B18 | ATCAAAACCAACCTCCAGTTCTCG | GTTTCAAATCGCAGAGTTCATCCTTCCT |
emh11B19 | ATCAAAACCAACCTCCAGTTCTCG | GTTTCAAATCGCAGAGTTCATCCTTCCT |
SSR125 | CCTAAAGAAGATAGGAAGAAATGCC | TCTCTCCTACTGAAACAACCAA |
The polymorphism information content (PIC) value for each SSR locus was computed using the formula PIC = 1-∑pi2, where pi is the frequency of the ith allele in the set of 42 eggplant genotypes studied (Weir BS 1990). The POPGENE 1.31 program by Yeh et al. (1999) was used to calculate the observed number of alleles, effective number of alleles (Ne), He, Nei’s expected heterozygosity (Nei’s), and Shannon’s information index (I). In all eggplant genotypes investigated, amplified fragments were evaluated for the presence (1) or lack (0) of the corresponding bands. Based on the binary data, cluster analysis was performed using NTSYS-PC version 2.1 and the unweighted pair group method with arithmetic averages (UPGMA). The results are presented as a dendrogram using the
Statistical analysis revealed a highly significant (p ≤ 0.01) difference for the traits under study (Table
Analysis of variance for growth and yielding traits of 42 eggplant genotypes.
SOV | df | D50%F | FH | NB | PH | FL | FD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rep | 2 | 0.929ns | 7.452* | 2.560* | 67.980* | 1.664ns | 2.450* |
Genotypes | 41 | 65.531** | 67.094** | 11.432** | 178.612** | 99.685** | 120.854** |
Error | 82 | 0.790 | 1.160 | 0.334 | 18.938 | 1.165 | 0.692 |
SOV | df | FL/D | AFW | FW | NF | Y/p | |
Rep | 2 | 0.005ns | 1356.716ns | 0.257ns | 0.568ns | 0.014ns | |
Genotypes | 41 | 0.435** | 9773.90** | 41523.90** | 96.251** | 4.148** | |
Error | 82 | 0.006 | 0.459 | 0.516 | 0.400 | 0.010 |
Mean performance of growth and yielding traits of 42 eggplant genotypes.
Genotypes | D50%F | FH | NB | PH | FD | FL |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MCV1 | 67.33fghi | 79.33ghij | 8.57defg | 69.48l-p | 15.98opq | 19.50kl |
MCV2 | 64.00 lm | 76.33lm | 7.55hijk | 77.947d-j | 16.17nop | 15.10qr |
MCV3 | 69.33d | 81.67e | 6.78kl | 75.89e-m | 29.91cd | 19.53kl |
MCV4 | 73.67bc | 85.67d | 5.67 m | 75.00e-n | 14.73q | 13.60rs |
MCV5 | 74.00b | 86.67 cd | 7.56hijk | 86.66b | 17.83jkm | 21.03k |
MCV6 | 64.00lm | 76.33 lm | 7.64ghijk | 73.72f-n | 15.17pq | 17.30nop |
MCV7 | 67.33fghi | 79.67fghij | 7.67ghijk | 84.33bcd | 19.30hij | 28.20cde |
MCV8 | 77.33a | 89.33ab3 | 6.33ml | 71.78i-o | 28.73d | 16.73opq |
MCV9 | 65.33jkl | 78.00jkl | 7.67ghijk | 79.33c-g | 10.00u | 10.70u |
MCV10 | 67.33fghi | 79.67fghij | 6.78kl | 76.89e-k | 17.04lmno | 26.90def |
MCV11 | 77.67a | 90.00a | 5.67 m | 77.11e-k | 12.97rs | 29.60bc |
MCV12 | 64.00 lm | 76.33 lm | 9.67ab | 70.34k-p | 25.47e | 19.03lmn |
MCV13 | 57.33q | 69.67o | 9.33abcd | 66.44o-r | 10.67tu | 11.93stu |
MCV14 | 69.33d | 81.33ef | 7.78fghij | 71.56j-o | 25.27e | 18.70lmn |
MCV15 | 64.33klm | 76.33lm | 4.11o | 71.56j-o | 13.20r | 15.77pq |
MCV16 | 68.67def | 81.00efg | 6.33ml | 81.33b-e | 18.35jkl | 22.90j |
MCV17 | 66.33hij | 78.67hij | 4.67no | 72.56g-o | 17.47lmn | 23.47ij |
MCV18 | 59.67p | 72.00n | 3.78op | 68.72n-q | 19.73ghi | 17.60mno |
MCV19 | 57.33q | 69.67o | 2.89qp | 75.89e-m | 25.47e | 23.20ij |
CCV1 | 66.67ghij | 80.00efghi | 7.56hijk | 73.67f-n | 17.37lmn | 24.50hij |
CCV2 | 66.67ghij | 79.33ghij | 8.47defgh | 79.00d-h | 20.52fgh | 28.63cd |
CCV3 | 67.33fghi | 79.67fghij | 6.00ml | 86.22bc | 19.73ghi | 25.50fgh |
CCV4 | 69.00de | 81.67e | 5.44mn | 76.44e-l | 30.91bc | 18.55lmn |
CCV5 | 67.67efgh | 80.00efghi | 8.11fghi | 78.78d-i | 30.94bc | 20.03kl |
CCV6 | 65.67jk | 78.00jkl | 6.33ml | 79.67b-f | 18.13jklm | 26.51efg |
TCV1 | 72.33c | 85.67d | 6.00ml | 77.11e-l | 24.83e | 19.57kl |
TCV2 | 64.33klm | 76.67klm | 2.67q | 60.78rs | 19.13ijk | 31.50a |
TCV3 | 68.67def | 81.00efg | 2.55q | 61.95qrs | 18.10jklm | 17.63mno |
TCV4 | 67.33fghi | 79.67fghij | 9.33a-d | 68.89m-q | 19.17ijk | 19.10 lm |
TCV5 | 63.67mn | 76.33lm | 8.66c-f | 79.22c-g | 18.37jkl | 24.83ghi |
TCV6 | 68.00defg | 80.33efgh | 5.99ml | 78.22d-j | 11.81st | 12.50st |
TCV7 | 63.33mn | 75.67m | 9.22bcde | 73.56f-n | 16.98mno | 17.73mno |
TCV8 | 65.67jk | 78.00jkl | 9.55abc | 73.55f-n | 18.87ijk | 17.70mno |
TCV9 | 67.67efgh | 80.00efghi | 7.78ghij | 63.78p-s | 11.83st | 11.80tu |
TCV10 | 62.33no | 75.67 m | 5.78 m | 72.00h-o | 16.47nop | 26.37 fg |
TCV11 | 73.67bc | 85.67d | 7.33ijk | 68.00n-q | 21.77f | 12.70st |
TCV12 | 66.67ghij | 79.00hij | 8.67cdef | 86.67b | 16.80mno | 30.63ab |
TCV13 | 66.00ij | 78.33ijk | 10.22a | 78.11d-j | 20.69fg | 17.37m-p |
TCV14 | 61.00op | 72.67n | 8.33efgh | 70.44k-p | 11.07tu | 10.53u |
TCV15 | 59.67p | 71.33no | 8.00fghi | 99.55a | 10.93tu | 11.63tu |
TCV16 | 74.67b | 87.67bc | 6.89jkl | 64.45p-s | 31.31b | 15.50q |
TCV17 | 65.67jk | 78.00jkl | 4.22o | 59.33s | 36.57a | 17.60mno |
Mean | 66.86 | 79.24 | 6.89 | 74.66 | 19.74 | 19.42 |
SEM | 0.42 | 0.43 | 0.18 | 0.76 | 0.52 | 0.56 |
LSD (p = 0.05) | 1.44 | 1.75 | 0.94 | 7.07 | 1.75 | 1.35 |
Genotypes | FL/D | FW (g) | AFW (g) | FN | Y/P (kg) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
MCV1 | 1.22hij | 148.51fgh | 130.32kl | 29.60ijk | 2.38mnopq |
MCV2 | 0.94p-s | 44.61rs | 106.49opqr | 27.93klmn | 1.58tuvw |
MCV3 | 0.65vw | 112.58kl | 184.11defg | 29.53ijk | 3.96cde |
MCV4 | 0.92qrs | 97.37ml | 173.70fgh | 23.60p | 2.92ijkl |
MCV5 | 1.18h-l | 139.78ghi | 136.04kjl | 31.03hi | 2.66lmn |
MCV6 | 1.14i-m | 62.41pq | 120.75l-p | 27.30mn | 1.92qrst |
MCV7 | 1.46de | 279.52b | 162.30hi | 38.20b | 4.29bc |
MCV8 | 0.58wx | 151.64efg | 179.41efgh | 26.73no | 3.46efgh |
MCV9 | 1.07k-o | 155.29efg | 192.05cde | 20.37r | 2.89ijkl |
MCV10 | 1.58cd | 196.15c | 136.54jkl | 36.90bc | 3.19hijk |
MCV11 | 2.29a | 43.02rst | 110.23nopq | 38.60b | 2.31nopqr |
MCV12 | 0.75uv | 40.21rstu | 110.01nopq | 28.70jklm | 1.72stu |
MCV13 | 1.12j-n | 94.02mn | 167.02igh | 27.37mn | 2.57lmno |
MCV14 | 0.74uv | 132.29hij | 164.89hi | 28.37jklmn | 3.26ghij |
MCV15 | 1.20h-k | 40.83rstu | 127.86klmn | 25.43o | 1.97pqrst |
MCV16 | 1.25ghi | 123.88ijk | 133.11kl | 32.90g | 2.73klmn |
MCV17 | 1.35efg | 153.61efg | 123.33lmno | 33.47fg | 2.45lmnop |
MCV18 | 0.89rst | 163.83def | 269.38a | 27.27mn | 5.97a |
MCV19 | 0.91rst | 173.82d | 165.75hi | 32.53gh | 3.77def |
CCV1 | 1.42ef | 53.83pqrs | 110.97m-q | 34.17efg | 2.08opqrs |
CCV2 | 1.39ef | 19.73w | 98.37qrs | 38.30b | 1.85rst |
CCV3 | 1.29fgh | 112.85kl | 171.05f-i | 35.50cde | 4.30bc |
CCV4 | 0.60xw | 154.03efg | 172.62f-i | 28.88jklm | 3.53defgh |
CCV5 | 0.64vw | 166.39de | 176.21efgh | 30.03ij | 3.79def |
CCV6 | 1.46de | 66.30op | 154.33ij | 36.18 cd | 3.77def |
TCV1 | 0.79tu | 164.20def | 201.50 cd | 29.57ijk | 4.47b |
TCV2 | 1.64c | 120.77jk | 129.88kl | 41.83a | 3.34fghi |
TCV3 | 0.98o-r | 27.68tuvw | 107.14opqr | 27.63lmn | 1.58stuv |
TCV4 | 1.00o-r | 25.20uvw | 94.36qrs | 29.10jkl | 1.29uvwx |
TCV5 | 1.35efg | 121.27jk | 134.27kl | 34.83def | 2.93ijkl |
TCV6 | 1.06l-p | 79.47no | 206.76c | 22.50pq | 3.52efgh |
TCV7 | 1.04m-q | 22.42vw | 90.45rs | 27.73lmn | 1.12vwx |
TCV8 | 0.94p-s | 17.23w | 86.03s | 27.37mn | 0.98x |
TCV9 | 1.00n-r | 37.75stuv | 127.21klmn | 21.80qr | 1.68stu |
TCV10 | 1.60c | 152.24efg | 129.16klm | 35.70cde | 2.83jklm |
TCV11 | 0.58wx | 49.61qrs | 135.47kl | 23.03pq | 1.97pqrst |
TCV12 | 1.82b | 178.71d | 142.02jk | 40.63a | 3.74defg |
TCV13 | 0.84stu | 54.89pqr | 198.09cd | 21.93pqr | 4.03bcd |
TCV14 | 0.95o-s | 18.06w | 102.49pqrs | 20.53r | 1.08wx |
TCV15 | 1.07l-o | 18.23w | 101.21qrs | 21.63qr | 1.10vwx |
TCV16 | 0.50x | 201.37c | 185.45def | 25.50o | 3.45fgh |
TCV17 | 0.48x | 303.83a | 249.00b | 27.60lmn | 5.49a |
Mean | 1.09 | 120.49 | 154.91 | 29.71 | 2.85 |
SEM | 0.03 | 10.40 | 5.04 | 0.50 | 0.10 |
LSD (p = 0.05) | 0.13 | 1.17 | 1.10 | 1.03 | 0.20 |
The seventeen SSR markers used demonstrated successful amplification (Table
SSR Locus | Na | F | Ne | I | He | PIC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
emf01K16 | 2 | 0.57 | 1.96 | 0.68 | 0.50 | 0.37 |
emb01D10 | 2 | 0.76 | 1.57 | 0.55 | 0.37 | 0.36 |
emh21J12 | 2 | 0.52 | 2.00 | 0.69 | 0.50 | 0.37 |
SSR–46 | 2 | 0.57 | 1.96 | 0.68 | 0.50 | 0.37 |
emh02E08 | 2 | 0.55 | 1.98 | 0.69 | 0.50 | 0.37 |
emh11I06 | 2 | 0.52 | 2.00 | 0.69 | 0.50 | 0.37 |
eme05B09 | 2 | 0.50 | 2.00 | 0.69 | 0.50 | 0.38 |
emb01C12 | 4 | 0.36 | 3.63 | 1.33 | 0.73 | 0.29 |
eme05B10 | 3 | 0.41 | 2.91 | 1.08 | 0.66 | 0.37 |
emh11B18 | 3 | 0.43 | 2.77 | 1.05 | 0.65 | 0.40 |
emh11B19 | 3 | 0.43 | 2.80 | 1.06 | 0.65 | 0.58 |
SSR40 | 2 | 0.83 | 1.36 | 0.45 | 0.28 | 0.58 |
SSR125 | 2 | 0.60 | 1.93 | 0.68 | 0.49 | 0.68 |
emf21K08 | 3 | 0.34 | 2.97 | 1.09 | 0.67 | 0.64 |
emk03O04 | 4 | 0.33 | 3.79 | 1.36 | 0.74 | 0.56 |
emk04N11 | 2 | 0.52 | 2.00 | 0.69 | 0.50 | 0.57 |
emf01E10 | 3 | 0.75 | 1.68 | 0.73 | 0.41 | 0.37 |
Average | 2.53 | 0.53 | 2.31 | 0.84 | 0.54 | 0.45 |
The seventeen SSR markers were selected based on the Euclidean distances between the 42 eggplant genotypes to create a UPGMA dendrogram, as shown in Table
Relationship among the 42 eggplant genotypes based on seventeen SSR markers using SAHN clustering using the UPGMA method.
Cluster | No of Accessions | Accessions | Origin |
---|---|---|---|
I | 16 | CV2, CV3, CV5, CV6, MV1, MV5, MV14, MV15, MC16, MV18, MV19, TV5, TV2, TV6, TV12 and TV13 | China (4) |
Malaysia (7) | |||
Thailand (5) | |||
II | 5 | MV2, MV4, MV9, MC14, and TV11 | Malaysia (4) |
Thailand (1) | |||
III | 10 | CV1, CV4, MV7, TV1, TV4, TV8, TV10, TV15, TV16 and TV17 | China (2) |
Malaysia (1) | |||
Thailand (7) | |||
IV | 5 | MV3, MV8, MV9, MV10, TV7 | Malaysia (4) |
Thailand (1) | |||
V | 6 | MV6, MV12, MV13, MV17, TV3, and TV14 | Malaysia (4) |
Thailand (2) |
The genetic structure of fruit yield is determined by the overall performance of various yield components that interact with each other. The 42 eggplant genotypes exhibited variation in terms of their physical and genetic diversity. The presence of genetic variation suggests that they may have originated from different sources, which explains the differences in their traits. This research provides information about the genetic variation of a specific group of eggplants, which can be valuable for future studies. The use of SSR markers is important in understanding the genetic connections among different eggplant genotypes from Malaysia, China and Thailand.
Conceptualization, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa) and M.R.Y. (Mohd Rafii Yusop); methodology, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa) and M.R.Y. (Mohd Rafii Yusop); software, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa), S.C.C. (Samuel Chibuike Chukwu); validation, U.M. (Usman Magaji); formal analysis, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa), M.R.Y. (Mohd Rafii Yusop), U.M. (Usman Magaji) and I.M. (Isma’ila Muhammad); investigation, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa) and B.Y.R. (Bashir Yusuf Rini); resources, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa) and M.R.Y. (Mohd Rafii Yusop); data curation, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa) and A.S.K. (Audu Sanusi Kiri); writing—original draft preparation, I.M. (Ibrahim Musa); writing—review and editing, A.F.A. (Arolu Fatai Ayanda) and I.M. (Ibrahim Musa); All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.